An Unequal Marriage

Why the Millennium Development Goals is an impossible dream unless local governance is wedded to better global stewardship

Philip Monaghan

Eco cities’, urban ‘place-making’, and the ‘big society’ – what do these things have in common? The answer is they are all concepts of sustainable settlements (low carbon and more equal and prosperous living) that are most likely doomed to failure. Why will they falter? These visions for local self-determination are fragile if they are not connected to resolving transnational governance problems ranging from reform of the international banking system through to achieving the Millennium Development Goals. Vice versa, global efforts to move beyond GDP as the primary measure of development or to adapt to climate change can be undermined by weak local leadership.

Seminal thinking over the past four decades, from Schumacher’s Small is Beautiful (in the 1970s) to A Future Worth Choosing by the UN’s High-Level Panel on Global Sustainability (released in January 2012) have gone some way to highlighting the point without quite being able to square this circle.

The bottom line is that we live in a complex and connected world. Opting out of the system at the household or national level is simply not a viable option.

Take, for instance, the proliferation of credit unions or other alternative forms of responsible lending that aim to help regenerate poor neighbourhoods. These communities are not insulated from the failings of global market mechanisms. If we do not rein in the credit ratings agencies, as a first step towards sorting out the financial ecosystem, then firms like Moody’s, Fitch and S&P will still have the power to make nations go bust. When they downgrade the creditworthiness of countries like Italy and the USA, the cost of borrowing goes up. This slows the pace of recovery from the recession, but, more than this, it hurts the poor the most.

Another illustration is the rise of national strategies on the green economy, be it for reasons of energy security, competing in the $5 trillion cleantech marketplace, or the huge costs of extreme weather. As is the case in the UK, these policy roadmaps can often focus on what the central government will do and what is expected of business, without making much (if any) reference to the vital role of city majors and other municipal leaders in the great transition. After all, from Amsterdam to Toyama, it is the local governments who are responsible for flood defence, retraining the local workforce in green skills and spatial planning that supports fossil-free public transport and district heating. Indeed these urban centres increasingly innovate in such fields to the extent that their thinking is way ahead of government strategy. (E.g. California setting the nation’s highest renewable energy target or ecosystem services in Quito to counter water scarcity.) Thus any fractured approach to decarbonising a country’s economy is simply bad news for everyone – worse still, a lack of collaboration wastes finite resources during a time of austerity.

In summary, we cannot have a strong nation if we do not have resilient local places. And if we want local places that are resilient we need to sort out some big international problems too. Identifying the key leverage points and then making the smartest interventions requires an understanding of this complex system.

An article by Philip Monaghan. Read the original at

Sustainability in AusterityPhilip Monaghan is a writer and strategist in the fields of economic development and environmental sustainability. He is Founder & CEO of Infrangilis and the acclaimed author of the books How Local Resilience Creates Sustainable Societies (Routledge, 2012) and Sustainability in Austerity (Greenleaf, 2010).

Buy Sustainability in Austerity direct from Greenleaf Publishing and receive a further 10% discount on top of the on-line price. Just use voucher code SDFGH at checkout.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s